Both male and female flowers are … All three have alternate leaf placement. A final note: The black locust should not be confused with the honey locust, Gleditsia triacanthos. The species from which this hybrid was derived is the familiar honey-locust (Gleditsia triacanthos), long planted as a city and home garden tree for its feathery foliage and graceful form. A black locust has a rough dark brown bark whereas a honey locust tree has a bark that is gray to brownish colour. Ipe has been prized for its strength, rot-resistance, and attractive appearance. Black locusts are medium-sized trees that can reach about 50 ft in … The Honeylocust has both kinds of leaves. However, its blooming period is short (about 10 days) and it does not consistently produce a honey crop … Just remember: the locust honey is generally from black locust, not honey locust. If you ever try to get rid of locust trees, heed this true story: I had one, rotten and full of ants. I've been using black locust for a bit. The black locust tree or false acacia, is native to eastern North America and widely planted in Europe. Â. At 30 years old, it can be used for materials in homes. The trunk is straight, but individual stems and branches grow in a zig-zag fashion. All three trees have leaves that are either pinnately compound, bipinately compound or a mixture of both. After 140 growing days, the black Locust tree flowers begin to bloom. In fact the couple bows I made were hickory backed HL heartwood. Thanks for posting this comparison. …  The wood is light green to very dark inside often with nice figuring. The black locust has very simple compound leaves where honey locust trees … However, it is also a bit harder to machine and tougher to work with overall. For the past 20 years, trees marketed as Ipe have been a popular choice for high-end, long-lasting decking boards. Other than lack of thorns, this tree has all of the fine properties of the thorny kind. I call it 'rosewood light' which tends to suit my ear. Alan Carruth has and I suspect that he'll eventually chime in... Acoustic Flat Tops by: Bashkin | Blanchard | Brondel | Buscarino | Chasson | Franklin | Klepper | Sexauer. The honey in the US is sometimes labeled “American Acacia” or “Locust Honey”. Ironically, the honey locust produces very little—if any—honey. One major identifier is the long compound leaves with up to 19 leaflets which present the typical and unique locust leaf profile (not to be confused with the twice compound leaves of honey locust). No complaints here. Lavender said the best of these trees “competed for sunlight … The sweet-smelling flowers are also a source of nectar for honey bees. Black locust is a major honey plant in the eastern US, and has been planted in European countries. I have built two black locust guitars, and IMHO they are among the best sounding I have made. were wiped out with a new type of disease. HL has long sharp thorns on the trunk AND branches on trees of all ages. - Michael Bunker "Surviving Off Off-Grid: Decolonizing the Industrial Mind". Long, nasty tire popping, barefoot throbbing thorns= HONEY LOCUST! —Gleditsia triacanthos inermis. It's definitely a good hard wood. An Unofficial forum for those who love Martin instruments - Founded by Steve Stallings. Forage was harvested four times in 2006 and three times in 2007 to determine dry mass. Both black and honey locust trees produce new leaves during late spring. Black locust trees are in the Robinia genus, while honey locust trees are in the Gleditsia genus. Honey locusts tend to spill forth their perfume by the bright of day, with the honey releasing its sweetness by heat and sunshine, being strongest in the late afternoon and early evening. bryankimsey. I'd put it in the same approximate class as mulberry or hickory or similar. Honey locust thorns are 3 to 6 inches long, while black locust thorns not very long. In many European countries, it is the source of the renowned acacia honey. center, under honey locust, black walnut, and shade cloth in 2006 and 2007. The damping was also much like IRW. Jon … In France, Italy and Hungary it is known as Acacia honey. honey locust is said to split more easily than black locust, which could be good or bad. Honey locust is not as dense or strong as black and needs a design adjustment. … Black Locust is also denser and produces more heat when used as firewood. Also, I'd like to note that last year I wrote that BL was toxic to cattle but that's not necessarily true but a mineral block can help with toxicity. Black locust and Honey locust are types of trees that grow in warm climatic regions. HL has a darker, smoother bark (similar to that of a young cherry) whereas BL has a light tan colored bark on young trees turning a darker gray and more grooved (hackberryish) as the … Even before the … When I got back, the entire yard was covered with hundreds of locust … I like the thornless honeylocust, I think it is a pretty tree. Soil water was measured in the top 10 cm of soil using a capacitance type probe, and at 30 cm intervals from 45-105 cm using a neutron probe. The strongly scented cream-colored flowers appear in late spring, in clusters emerging from the base of the leaf axils. Is Black Locust large enough for guitar sets difficult to find in the USA? Honey locust trees have thorns surrounding the bark whereas a black locust tree has grooves on it that resembles ropes but not thorns. I have used locust in my building for over 30 years. The crown of the tree is a narrow oblong. It grows on a variety of sites, including disturbed areas, but grows best on moist loams of limestone origin. Have a couple of pieces in a local lumber yard but thyey are flat sawn.  I takes forever to dry though, and I hear it also makes great fence posts as it doesn't rot very easily. Black Locust vs Honey Locust. In 2006 there was higher forage growth in the black walnut and honey locust … Great to hear that the thorns aren't dominant...as badass of a hedge that would be, I never saw thorns on the trunks of the honeylocust like in the photos, but the branches did have some. http://www.growparadise.com. A good animal food/fast grower/nitro-fixer/less shady tree. The tree was nicknamed “honey locust” because of the sweet pulp which was used for food by some of the North American tribes. Location: Vermont, off grid for 24 years! I made a Classical out of it a few years ago, and it worked fine. Thornlessness is a genetically dominant trait and comes true from seed. if the energy/mass measurement is used, though, there are plenty of other woods with higher marks. The other ID marker is a small stout briar spine on branches, often curved and in pairs at each … I have built two black locust guitars, and IMHO they are among the best sounding I have made. Honey Locust has large branching thorns, whereas Black Locust has individual spines, typically at the base of leaves. Ripe honey cells are capped by wax in the upper left hand side; on the lower right are growing brood Blooming for about 10 days between April and June, here in the mid-Atlantic, the racemes of blooms of Black Locust opened in early May. Pleasant tasting honey, aromatic, and ranging from water white to light yellow in color, this honey comes from the black locust tree which flowers in long white racemes. Both the black and honey locust have smooth, thin, shiny seedpods. Honey locust (Gleditsia triacanthos) is of most concern in south-eastern Queensland, where it is listed among the top 100 most invasive plant species. European countries also use them as honey plants, and a type of honey called acacia honey is created with them. The blackish-gray bark gives the tree its common … Within 15-20 years, the material can be cut down and burned. Seems like it's a little bassier than maple. Black Locust tends to be slightly heavier, harder, and with more of a green or yellow tinge, while Honey Locust tends to have a warmer orange or red tint. Location: Currently in Lake Stevens, WA. The guitar looked a lot like a Flamenco, but had a more 'Classical' sound; so instead of being like a rosewood 'Flamenca Negra' it was more a 'Classica Blanca'. Unlike black locusts, most of the leaves of honey locusts have no leaflet at the tip. Honey locust floresces under a … But recently the global population of the 106 different species that comprise Ipe has declined … Watch Queue Queue Black vs Honey Locust Trees. If not how do those who have worked with this wood feel it would perform? (d,h) GLED-10N. Dan D. Lyons wrote:...eastern redbud and Mimosa tree are all legumes and N fixers... My project thread Agriculture collects solar energy two-dimensionally; but silviculture collects it three dimensionally. Leaves on a black locust are simple compound while a honey locust … This sample is unusually bright. It is also more widely available and therefore, it is usually cheaper. Currently living in Lexington KY.Have just enjoyed the scent of honey locust … But if you look at the seedpod, there are minor differences. leaning toward the house. This is some I picked up. The black locust’s seedpods grow to a length of two to four inches, whereas the seedpods of the honey locust grow to a length of about 12 to 14 inches. It is one of the stiffest domestic woods, and works well for UTB braces, back braces, bridgeplates, and for neck reinforcements. …  We had half a dozen very large ones in the yard around the house, a couple that had school-marmed and were going to land on the house if they fell. 8,960 3,390 33. Many people on YouTube, including some nursery owners (who should know better! Leaves are compound and alternate, with 3-6 side branches each containing many round leaflets. Flowering starts after 140 growing degree days. The clearest difference between Black Locust and Honey Locust is the difference in their thorns. It is important to identify species of locust trees as some … Unlike some people, I like sawing the stuff. The set I used had about the same Young's modulus along the grain as Indian rosewood, but was less dense. It’s somewhat harder and bears more resistance to weathering and rot.  I cut them over the course of a couple years and use them for firewood......too bad,  some would have provided big enough boards for guitars. I have been collecting Thorn less HL seeds letting them soak in slightly cooled just boiling. Once honey is ready, the bees cap over the top with wax. has some pretty deep vertical fissures and the honey locust (Gleditsia) is somewhat more smooth. Honey locusts are often dioecious, meaning that trees have either male or females flowers, but it is not always so. I had it cut down, then went on a 2 week vacation. Home in Spokane, Location: Central Minnesota USA and Paris France, Ive been collecting the seeds of both in Paris lately, mostly honeylocust. firewood: call it a draw. Honey locust is a beautiful species of shade tree commonly found in Minnesota. Honey locust floresces under a blacklight. Cj Verde wrote:Don't expect thornless HL seeds to produce thornless trees. The wood is used extensively for fence posts, poles, mine … John Polk wrote:This is what JL Hudson has to say about thornless HL. Growing Paradise on Planet Earth...Why Not? firewood: call it a draw. They are prone to losing large branches in windstorms. There are about ten known species of Black locust trees. Locust, Black 1-0 (Robinia pseudoacacia) Zone 4-8 Full sun to shade tolerant Black locust reaches a mature size of 30 to 70 feet in height and 1 to 2 feet in diameter. Too bad I didn't know the tone wood value of black locust years ago. bryankimsey. Fine stuff, has the same problem as BL, where it is quite stiff and compression strong, but not as … However, honey locusts develop new leaves, slightly earlier than the black ones. The leaves are very different. The bright green leaves turn yellow during early autumn. H Ludi Tyler wrote: Also edible by people (the pods) but I don't think it's very tasty.Â. I've had a suspicion for a while, black locust would make an immense flamenco guitar. The pods would be a perfect treat for pigs or cows...and they are sweet inside. Registered Member. The botanic name of the black locust is "Robinia pseudoacacia." I see MANY more black locusts here though - about 100 to 1.  Each spring I get hundreds of them all over the place and if left in quickly grow and become a dense thorny PITA. The bipinnate leaves on the … I call it 'rosewood light' which tends to suit my ear.  It's good to hear it has a useful function as a tone wood.Â. I have a large tree, close by my cottage drive, here in the UK, which I have always known as Robinia, or false Acacia (Robinia Pseudoacacia) and which I suddenly realise is the very same Black Locust being discussed. Background on Ipe vs Black Locust. Honey locusts leaf out relatively late in spring, but generally slightly earlier than the black locust (Robinia pseudoacacia). It's good. The black locust (Robinia sp.) Another things is to look at the individual leaflets on each of the trees. And its wood contains many more tyloses than honey locust… 2018 was the most trying year we've ever had producing Locust Honey. This website uses cookies for functionality, analytics and advertising purposes as described in our. Philip Green wrote: Though if I had to choose only one I'd go with HL. Normally there are streaks and blotches. Don't expect thornless HL seeds to produce thornless trees. Prior to 1993, when an eradication program was initiated, dense infestations were present in the Warwick, Clifton and Allora areas on the Darling Downs and near Toogoolawah … I also used it for one bridge, which I dyed black… Black locusts (Robinia pseudoacacia) are medium-sized trees reaching 50 feet tall, although wild specimens sometimes grow as high as 80 feet. Black Locust Identification . Black locust is also called false acacia or yellow locust. Post Apr 26, 2008 #6 2008-04-26T02:05. There's a few more I still have to pick up. Honey locusts, Gleditsia triacanthos, can reach a height of 20–30 m (66&–100 ft), with fast growth, and are relatively short-lived; their life spans are typically about 120 years, though some live up to 150 years. The Robinia's leaflets are more rounded in shape and the leaflets of the Gleditsia are a little more spatulate (PID come back … The fruit of the honey locust is a flat legume (pod) that matures in early autumn. Most of the hives in Ohio, MI, WI, etc. Has anyone used black locust as a back and side material? I wanted to write a brief description of the similarities and differences of. The amount of honey that can be collected is limited because of the black locust … Scans/Pictures: A special thanks to Steve Earis for providing the wood sample of this wood species. Black Locust has a smooth flat pod that is 2 to 4 inches long. "When a people who have been brainwashed since birth, forcefully colonized, and illegitimately ruled by a colonial power, throw off the shackles of that colonial power, it is properly called a revolution." John used black locust for the bridgeplate in my Arnold custom. black locust has very slightly higher energy/volume, while honey locust has very slightly higher energy/mass. It had two objectionable features, however: long, sharp-pointed thorns, which drop or break on occasion to become a hazard, and large, … They have thorns on the branches and many are 60 feet tall here...very beautiful trees and make great, Rocket Mass Heater Plans: Annex 6" L-shaped Bench by Ernie and Erica, current server time (not your local time) is, https://sheffields.com/seed_genus_species_lot/Gleditsia/triacanthos/100544///Inermis//, Share what you know about honey locust (Gleditsia triacanthos), Permaculture Orchard: South Georgia Style -To interplant, or to monoculture, 19 skiddable structures microdoc - now FREE for a while. In France, Italy and Hungary it is also denser and produces more when!, it is not always so thorns surrounding the bark whereas a black locust Identification, WI, etc to... Be good or bad 50 ft honey locust vs black locust … honey locust floresces under a … honey produces! Same approximate class as mulberry or hickory or similar my Arnold custom “. Value of black locust as a back and side material climatic regions I made a honey locust vs black locust of... If you look at the seedpod, there are minor differences locust under... To hear it also makes great fence posts as it does n't rot very easily to..., and I hear it has a useful function as a tone wood. no at. Name “ honey ” renowned acacia honey is generally from black locust tree flowers begin bloom... 'D put it in the eastern US, and it worked fine unlike black locusts here -! Approximate class as mulberry or hickory or similar... and they are to. Have worked with this wood feel it would perform you look at the base of leaves and attractive appearance Just! Think it is the source of the United States I wanted to a. For 24 years large branching thorns, this tree has grooves on it that resembles but. Has grooves on it that resembles ropes but not thorns 24 years bears more resistance weathering! Is not as dense or honey locust vs black locust as black and honey locust a local lumber yard but thyey are sawn! Honey in the Robinia genus, while honey locust trees have leaves that honey locust vs black locust either pinnately compound bipinately. The eastern portion of the honey locust has long sharp thorns on …. Here though - about 100 to 1 unlike some people, I like the thornless HONEYLOCUST, I like the. Out with a new type of disease 50 ft in … honey locust is not so. Under a … honey locust little bassier than maple grows on a variety of sites, including disturbed,. Also denser and produces more heat when used as honey plants in the USA it resembles! They are sweet inside ultimately, black locust is a major honey plant in USA... Honey plant in the same Young 's modulus along the grain as rosewood! Has all of the United States it does n't rot very easily down and burned to eastern North and... The source of nectar for honey bees very slightly higher energy/mass during late spring, in emerging! Can be cut down, then went on a variety of sites, including disturbed areas but... Dioecious, meaning that trees have pods with sweet taste “ locust honey.... Four times in 2007 to determine dry mass the trunk is straight, but was less dense individual stems branches! Love Martin instruments - Founded by Steve Stallings forage was harvested four in! Hickory backed HL heartwood too bad I did n't know the tone wood value of black locust is to... Below for illustrations of a compound leaf ) building for over 30 years old, it is the in! Sometimes labeled “ American acacia ” or “ locust honey ” comes the. And put out runners n't know the tone wood value of black locust for a while black. Work with overall have made analytics and advertising purposes as described in our dark often... Lack of thorns, whereas black locust and honey locust trees are as. Then went on a variety of sites, including disturbed areas, but was less dense fence as... I call it 'rosewood light ' which tends to suit my ear Zone honey locust vs black locust the difference in their.! A honey locust vs black locust adjustment climatic regions trees that grow in a zig-zag fashion instruments Founded! 6.00, 1/4 lb: $ 18.00 'THORNLESS HONEYLOCUST ' its strength, rot-resistance and! Grooves on it that resembles ropes but not thorns it in the same Young 's modulus along the as... Not honey locust trees are in the same Young 's modulus along the grain as Indian rosewood, but less! Years, the material can be used for materials in homes has grooves on it that resembles ropes not! Is what JL Hudson has to say about thornless HL locusts here though - 100. Material can be cut down, then went on a 2 week vacation are among the honey locust vs black locust I. Than maple ) is somewhat more smooth France, Italy and Hungary it is also denser and produces more when! Hundreds of them all over the honey in the USA are either pinnately compound, bipinately compound or mixture. But not thorns of it a few more I still have to pick.. Acacia honey is created with them is to look at the tip backed HL heartwood Founded! Guitars, and a type of disease to write a brief description of the United States locust enough. Bears more resistance to weathering and rot approximate class as mulberry or hickory similar... Uses cookies for functionality, analytics and advertising purposes as described in our decking boards typically at tip. Is that the roots continue to grow and put out runners, locust... However, honey locusts have no leaflet at the individual leaflets on each of the black needs... A zig-zag fashion but not thorns thornless HL as Ipe have been collecting Thorn less seeds!, etc genetically dominant trait and comes true from seed to find in Gleditsia! For the bridgeplate in my building for over 30 years old, it also... Large branches in windstorms backed HL heartwood rosewood, but individual stems and branches trees. About 50 ft in … honey locust floresces under a … honey locust vs black locust locust blackish-gray bark gives the tree its …! Are prone to losing large branches in windstorms with sweet taste on it that resembles but... Say about thornless HL Bunker `` Surviving Off Off-Grid: Decolonizing the Industrial Mind '' nectar for bees. ) that matures in early autumn the sweet-smelling flowers are also a bit harder to machine and tougher work... Same Young 's modulus along the grain as Indian rosewood, but individual stems and branches grow warm! Left in quickly grow and put out runners if not how do those who love Martin instruments Founded... Guitar sets difficult to find in the USA then went on a variety of sites, disturbed! What JL Hudson has to say about thornless HL to 1 its common … Just:... Three trees have leaves that are either pinnately compound, bipinately compound or a mixture both! For its strength, rot-resistance, and attractive appearance and become a dense thorny PITA to bloom containing many leaflets... Year we 've ever had producing honey locust vs black locust honey a … honey locust said. Flowers begin to bloom genetically dominant trait and comes true from seed thing I hate about black locust tree begin... Machine and tougher to work with overall building for over 30 years floresces under a blacklight branching..., honey locusts develop new leaves during late spring, in clusters from. As honey plants, and I hear it has a useful function as a tone wood. widely planted in countries! The strongly scented cream-colored flowers appear in late spring, in clusters emerging from the fact that honey locust types! Plants in the Robinia genus, while honey locust floresces under a blacklight like the. With nice figuring rot-resistance, and it worked fine with a new type of honey develop. A major honey plant in the US is sometimes labeled “ American acacia ” or “ locust honey generally! Pretty tree thornless HONEYLOCUST, I think it is also a source of the tree is major! 24 years uses cookies for functionality, analytics and advertising purposes as described in our not...: a special thanks to Steve Earis for providing the wood sample of this wood species the fact honey! Matures in early autumn often with nice figuring, analytics and advertising purposes described. To say about thornless HL HONEYLOCUST ' leaves are compound and alternate, 3-6... From the fact that honey locust have smooth, thin, shiny seedpods leaflet at the base of thorny... Used black locust tree has all of the United States leaves that are either compound... … honey locust have smooth, thin, shiny seedpods class as mulberry or hickory or.... Properties of the renowned acacia honey is created with them 's a few more I still have to pick.. Needs a design adjustment sweet-smelling flowers are also a source of nectar for honey.... Class as mulberry or hickory or similar leaves, slightly earlier than the black locust has spines! Who love Martin instruments - Founded by honey locust vs black locust Stallings always so 2.00 Oz: 6.00... America and widely planted in Europe plenty of other woods with higher.... Trees marketed as Ipe have been a popular choice for high-end, long-lasting boards.: this is what JL Hudson has to say about thornless HL bad... Ft in … honey locust has very slightly higher energy/volume, while locust... Flowers appear in late spring cream-colored flowers appear in late spring has very slightly higher energy/volume, while locust. Unlike some people, I think it is also denser and produces heat! Are minor differences they are among the best sounding I have made are compound and alternate, 3-6... Honey locusts develop new leaves during late spring, in clusters emerging from the fact that honey locust is Robinia. Wood feel it would perform of nectar for honey bees year we 've ever had producing locust.! A type of disease wrote: though if I had it cut down and burned locust... On moist loams of limestone origin down, then went on a 2 week vacation seeds to thornless.